Fifty Shades is such a ubiquitous part of the collective
unconscious that’s its spawned a TV series, Submission, in which the characters' fantasies are fueled by a book called The Slave (though creators of the series have tried to differentiate it as a more realistic portrayal of human sexuality than that of its predecessor). It’s a little
unrealistic to have a book like The Slave lying out everywhere, as it is in the series.
Usually you keep Fifty Shades clones, in a drawer or under a mattress. The Story of O, for all its notoriety, never had it so good. But what'd most interesting is the meta universe in which the series exists. Unlike Fifty Shades, the willing
suspension of disbelief is constantly cut short when characters wake up from
their fantasies. And daydreaming is really what Submission is about. Freud wrote The Interpretation of Dreams, but
someone could do an analysis of the show called The Interpretation of Daydreams. Further, the world in which the series takes place, in which much of the sex is catalyzed by fiction, is a comment on our
pornographic culture, in which those who read highly stimulating texts or go on
sites, are inundated with imagery that ultimately separates rather than unites them with others. So strong are the images that may have stimulated sex
that they end up overwhelming the sex itself, leaving the person who's fantasizing as solitary as he or she would have been were they simply
masturbating to the same scenarios. E. L. James may find herself writing yet
another sequel entitled Fifty Shades of
Janovic Paint to deal with the color combinations on the walls of the rooms in which the characters of Submission
live out their reveries of being enslaved.
Showing posts with label Submission. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Submission. Show all posts
Thursday, June 16, 2016
Monday, November 9, 2015
Knausgaard on Houellebecq
What a brilliant idea to assign a writer whose name is even
more unpronounceable that the writer he is reviewing? What an equally brilliant
idea to assign a writer whose work has achieved almost mythic status so that
his review is immune from the usual editing accorded a piece so that the
reviewer in question, a world class provocateur can take the kind of liberties
that would not normally be permitted in an otherwise august publication priding
itself on the illusion of objectivity. in making globalized statements about the
work of another equally transgressive personality! The novel in question is
Michel Houellebecq’s Submission: A Novel, a
futuristic jeremiad about France as an Islamic state, published on the same day
as the Charlie Hebdo massacre, during the week that Houellebecq’s image, in fact, graced the cover of the magazine. The Norwegian writer and author of Min Kamp (as in Hitler’s Mein Kampf), Karl Ove Knausgaard, begins
his front page New York Times Book Review assignment (NYT, 11/2/15) by making the startling admission that he has never
read anything by Houellebecq, despite the fact that the two authors, do for
modern European sexuality what John Cheever and John Updike did for the sexual
mores of 50’s suburban America and despite the fact that Houellebecq’s The Elementary Particles had been
particularly recommended to him, as a book of interest. He feels about Houellebecq the way way he does Lars von Trier; his reticence about both deriving from anticipated “envy." Here Knausgaard
maintains his high standards of provocativeness by thumbing his nose at his
editor for making the assignment. He goes even further, however, by pointing
out that he hasn’t read any of the works of the l9th century author of Against Nature, Joris-Karl Huysmans, whose works are central to Submission. So fuck you “hypocrite
lecture,-- mon semblable,-- mon frère!” Knausgaard employs a preternatural perspicacity along with his signature candor, as he concludes these “virgin" observations about his embattled continental colleague’s work: “The disillusioned gaze sees through everything,
sees all the lies and the pretenses we concoct to give life meaning, the only
thing it doesn’t see is its own origin, its own driving force. But what does
that matter as long as it creates great literature, quivering with ambivalence,
full of longing for meaning, which, if none is found, it creates itself?”
Friday, March 27, 2015
One-Dimensional Man?
There is a wonderful description of Michel Houellebecq in
Anthony Daniels’ New Criterion essay (“France’s ‘Submission,’” February
2015). Firstly here is Daniels on the
writer’s credo: “Houellebecq is a writer with a single underlying theme: the
emptiness of human existence in a consumer society devoid of religious belief,
political project, or cultural continuity in which, moreover, thanks to
material abundance and social security, there is no real struggle for existence
that might give meaning to the life of millions.” Put another away
Houellecbecq might be seen as the Zola of his generation. He is a determinist
who disparages enlightenment notions which only detract from the tragedy of the
inevitable. One might say that the anti-Christs in Houellebecq are the
inveterate optimists, for instance 60’s utopians, who believe in the notion of human
freedom. They remain paradoxically unenlightened enough not to realize the
extent to which, like a stampeding mob, they trample on the needs of others as
they seek to achieve their own private nirvanas. Daniels' essay comes on the
heels of the publication of Houellebecq’s latest novel in which as Daniels
states “a Muslim is elected President of France.” Houellebecq had at one point been charged in France when he publically stated Islam is "the most stupid religion” (“Calling Islam stupid lands author in court,” The Guardian, 9/17/02) Uncannily, his latest novel was released on January 7, the day of the Charlie Hebdo massacre. But here is Daniels' description of the author:
“Houellebecq’s physical appearance as relayed in the press suggests that he fully inhabits the world he describes. He
looks like a man who has crawled out of a giant ashtray after a prolonged
alcoholic binge in clothes that have not been washed for weeks.” Houellebecq would shudder but there is a
comparison to be made between him and Herbert Marcuse, the Frankfurt school
Berkeley philosopher who coined the term “repressive desublimation” in his famous tome One-Dimensional Man: Studies in the Ideology of Advanced Industrial Society. The two have different agendas, but
they might offer the same diagnosis about dark side of pleasure seeking. Houllebecq is now a film star too. He appears in The Kidnapping of Michel Houllebecq which just opened at Film Forum.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



