Jennifer Senior plucks up this quote from Wittgenstein in
her review of Madeleine Thien’s Do Not
Say We Have Nothing (NYT,
10/23/16), “the strength of the individual is wasted through the overcoming of
opposing forces & frictional resistances.” Thien’s novel concerns the plight
of classical musicians during China’s Cultural Revolution, but the Wittgenstein quote is timeless. If only Donald Trump had
read it before he started to go on about “rigged elections.” One can only
bemoan the fact that Wittgenstein and Donald Trump are unlikely bedfellows.
It’s fine to swim against the current, but sometimes you’re caught in a rip tide.Think about all the times when you could have better spent your
resources on productive activities than those which were destined not only to
go nowhere, but drain you of energy and leave you with a fundamentally negative
attitude about human existence. Hindsight is 20/20, but experience, which
should be a guide, often fails to be instructive due to that nasty little
troll, otherwise known as the unconscious need to fail. Daniel Kahneman has
dealt with this in books like Thinking:Fast and Slow, where he discusses irrational
drives which influence decision making. The Freudians have a term for this, Fehlleistung or "faulty achievement" which is the tendency to delight in doing
things that are bad for us. If only there were a crystal ball which could reveal whether it was the wrong move to embark on the five
volume biography of Milton Berle, modeled on Leon Edel’s canonical homage to Henry
James.
Showing posts with label Henry James. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Henry James. Show all posts
Tuesday, November 1, 2016
Wednesday, September 9, 2015
Sargent: Portraits of Artists and Friends
![]() |
| Madame X |
“Sargent: Portraits of Artists and Friends,” currently
showing at the Met, is a virtual vade mecum of l9th European culture, as seen
from the perspective of the great and often quirky transatlantic portraitist. There is Ellen Terry as Lady Macbeth (1889) and a sketch of Yeats (1908). The impressionist style of “Claude Monet Painting by the Edge of a Wood”(1885) shows Sargent’s mirror neurons at work. Henry James, whose novels provided a similar, albeit fictionalized portrait of European
cultural life, is pictured with his thumb in his coat. Edmund Booth (1890) is the
subject of a characteristically "dramatic" portrait. Rodin, who he painted, called him “the Vandyke of
our times.” The curators point to the fact that his portrait of Madame X (the
expatriate Madame Pierre Gautreau), shown bare shouldered in a sensual black
gown with silver straps, was deemed scandalous and resulted in Sargent’s
departure for England. "Dr. Pozzi at Home” (1881) evinces a similar swagger in its use of an
ecclesiastical red to capture the estheticism of a renowned gynecologist. But
it’s the poses that really distinguish these portraits. The current exhibit underscores the connection to Frans Hals’ “The Banquet of the Officers of the St. George Civic Guard,” (1616) in Sargent’s painting of of the artists Francois Flameng and Paul Helleu, with Flameng staring straight out and Helleu in profile. Sargent takes a similar tact in the painting of
the children of the playwright Edouard Pailleron with Marie-Louise facing out
with a look of self-possession that verges on possession and her brother
Edouard staring away in distraction. In a “A Dinner Table at Night" (1884) his
subject Edith Vickers commands our attention while her husband Alfred’s profile
is cut short, drifting into oblivion at the edge of the frame. James and
Sargent may have admired each other greatly, but looking at the current exhibit one
begins to ask who was the novelist and who the painter? They both had similar
themes but James painted with words and Sargent wrote novels in oil.
Thursday, December 6, 2012
The Joseph Epstein Cult
![]() |
| Photograph Chicago Tribune/Charles Osgood
Joseph Epstein’s “The James Cult” in the October 2012 The New Criterion is a terrific essay.
He calls himself a Jacobite, a wonderful locution in and of itself and then
goes on both laud and damn Michael Gorra’s Portrait of a Novel: Henry James and the Making of an American Masterpiece. Epstein
has always been a pundit in the best sense of the word, a pithy observer whose
aphoristic style is peppered with dense erudition. Here all that is at work. He says “the Jamesian sentence resembles a hawk, circling, circling, circling
before plunging downward to strike off a penetrating observation or startling
apercu. As subordinate clause piles upon subordinate clause…one occasionally
forgets that the sentence under investigation has a subject and predicate. And
yet, James’s style…did exactly what he wanted it to do, which was to capture
consciousness in all its complexity.” You can read the Edels and Gorras but
witness how beautifully and simply Epstein gets to the essence of his subject.
Epstein then uses his obvious inurement in James to refute Gorra’s championing
of what he terms "the Henry James Homosexual Project (HJHP)." “Chekhov claimed
that ‘medicine is my lawful wife and literature is my mistress',” Epstein writes.
“For James literature was wife and mistress both. Marriage was not for him. Nor
were dalliances, homo- or heterosexual…James would have considered it an insult
to his imagination to be told that he could only understand the power and
dignity of renunciation because he had himself practiced it.” Epstein may be
practicing some dubious psychology of his own in his arguing that artistic
production and sexual desire are mutually exclusive. It’s an idea that’s not
particularly vindicated by any of our modern Vasaris. But three cheers for leaving James alone. Artistic personalities are not sauces and they don’t
profit from the kind of reduction that Michael Gorra amongst others appears to
practice.
|
Saturday, June 12, 2010
Brief Encounter
Joyce termed sentimentality “unearned emotion.” The same could be said for melodrama. The film Brief Encounter
, based on Noël Coward's play Still Life
, is a classic piece of melodrama, pulled along by the engine of Rachmaninoff’s Piano Concerto Number #2. Stéphane Brizé’s Mademoiselle Chambon has all the ingredients of melodrama. The music, in this case more subtly rendered by the British composer Edward Elgar, underscores the impossible love relationship between a shiftless, cultivated school teacher and a Lawrentian construction worker, Jean, trapped in the provinces, with a muted pre-verbal physicality. If there is a Madame Bovary
in the film, it is in Jean’s muted aspiration for the world that Veronique Chambon represents. Yet there are so many lovely touches in Mademoiselle Chambon, underscored by the leitmotif of the window which runs through the film—the romance begins with Jean repairing Chambon’s window and ends with the vision of Jean and his wife Ann-Marie, now pregnant with a second child, viewed through a claustrophobic window shot. If there is any melodrama here, it is overshadowed by subtlety and artistry. In this regard, the movie is reminiscent of the understatement of Evan Connell’s Mr. and Mrs. Bridge
novels. The affair is only one of a series of life passages Jean confronts, including a visit to a mortician with his father to decide on interment or cremation. Jean leaves a message on Veronique’s answering machine culminating in the simple phrase, “C’etait Jean,” and Veronique’s students write “Au revoir Mademoiselle Chambon” on a blackboard. In another exchange, Ann Marie says, “I think your father enjoyed his birthday,” to which Jean replies, “Yes, it was a good party.” In a previous epiphanic scene, Ann Marie, having seen the way her husband looks at his son’s teacher, understands everything. What is truly moving about Mademoiselle Chambon are the succession of moments that contain what Henry James
termed “felt life.” In the end, Madame Chambon earns its emotion.
Thursday, December 31, 2009
Swells
Every red blooded American boy needs to experience dispossession. It’s what makes America great and it’s what creates the dynamic quality of American life, to the extent that this country has no real hereditary aristocracy (as De Tocqueville pointed out in Democracy in America). The downstairs of one generation can become master of the house in the next. Joseph Losey’s The Servant (with screenplay by Harold Pinter) brilliantly captured the potentiality for such role reversals in the British context. In America, Raymond Carver was the poet of dispossession. Latter-day incarnations, like the short-story writer Wells Tower, whose work has received a great deal of critical attention, wear dispossession on their sleeves, but Carver exuded what Henry James called “felt life.” In one famous passage, a garage sale becomes an emblematic act of self-revelatory excoriation.
After the stock market crash of l929, many of the entitled saw their fortunes fade, and more recently many great families who had invested in blue-chip firms like Lehman Brothers saw their fortunes turn sour overnight. There are undoubtedly support groups for super wealthy individuals whose net worth dropped from hundreds to tens of millions in the market turmoil. What would it be like without Aspen and Palm Beach, without the Connaught and the Hotel du Cap, without Gstaad and Cortina in the winter? Everything in America occurs at such breakneck speed that there is really no time to accommodate a leisure class. By the time one generation has accumulated enough wealth to live like royalty, the wealth is already gone and they are writing memoirs, or, like the Beales of Grey Gardens fame, they're the subjects of documentaries about the decline of yet another age of swells.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




