 |
| William D. Hamilton |
In a review of Ullica Segerstrale’s biography of the
evolutionary biologist William D. Hamilton (
“Inclusive Fitness," TLS 8/2/13),
Nature’s Oracle: The Life and Work of W.D. Hamilton Jennie Erin Smith makes
the following comment “The concept of inclusive fitness argued that an organism
could increase its genetic success not merely by reproducing itself, but also
by aiding the reproduction and survival of relatives carrying some proportion of
identical genes.” What Hamilton was trying to deal with was essentially
altruism or “why an animal should forego reproducing…or expose itself to danger
to warn its fellows of a predator.” When you think of it altruism is actually contradicted by natural
selection. Yet rather than being an aporia, it falls into a category that is
becoming increasingly common amongst high level thinkers in both science and
philosophy. For instance Thomas Nagel, who defines himself as an atheist, still
maintains in his current book
Mind and Cosmos, that pure naturalism cannot effectively explain the emergence of
consciousness. The “inclusiveness”of a thinker like Nagel bears comparison to Hamilton who also exhibits a kind of scientific thinking that takes nothing for granted. But Hamilton who believed in Segerstrale’s
words that warfare “could be seen...as adaptive rather than pathological” could also be quite provocative. Thinkers like Hamilton and Nagel, along with the utilitarian philosopher Peter Singer of
Animal Liberation fame are part of the “more things in heaven and earth” club who ask uncomfortable and bothersome questions that are bound to upset the applecart for purists who are unable to tolerate a multivalent view of the world. Philosophic and scientific multitasking is the name of this game.