Tuesday, August 18, 2015

Slavery vs. Freedom?: A Cost Analysis

Is there an advantage to being a slave rather than a minimum wage worker, who lives on a subsistence salary? A slave is a piece of property that needs to be maintained, just like a car or tractor. Hence from a health point of view, the situation of the slave is better than that of many workers in America, who still struggle with health costs, despite the advances of Obamacare. A slave like a pet also has to be fed and treated with plenty of TLC, otherwise it will become squirrelly and indolent. Repeated punishments and beatings have not been found to increase the effectiveness of slaves. Minimum wage workers, however, require little TLC. If a worker in a fast food joint doesn’t perform his job, there’s always a replacement waiting in the wings. Of course, freedom is the one thing that slaves don’t have. Everyone talks about freedom and dreams of it, but once it arrives its benefits fall far short of the promise that was once held out. Sure it’s nice to be free, but freedom like independence means that you end up having to fend for yourself. It’s nice to be free if you can hack it, but if you end up having a hard time in an increasingly competitive marketplace, then you may want think about relinquishing your freedom. In general, when you create a spread sheet and list all the pluses and minuses of freedom versus slavery, you’re going to find that it’s a very close call. Would you rather be enslaved by a relatively nice owner, say a Thomas Jefferson type, or work for McDonald’s for the rest of your life?

1 comment:

  1. PLEASE don't be flippant about the condition of slaves in the U.S. Despite the common sense insight that says people will be kind and careful with their human property--because property is expensive and they own it, common observation shows that people aren't. How many mistreat their washing machines, air conditioners, automobiles? And their pets! Just ask the ASPCA.

    As for human property, there are ample records of chronic horrible treatment. See Frances Kemble for example. [ www.gutenberg.org/files/12422/12422.../12422-h.htm ] The sainted Thomas Jefferson staved off bankruptcy at his beloved Monticello with a profitable little nail factory, where boys, 10 and 11, were made to hammer them out of metal rods crouching over the anvils summer and winter, 6 days out of the 7.
    [http://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/the-dark-side-of-thomas-jefferson-35976004/?no-ist=&page=2] Oh yes they were beaten and terrorized to prevent "slacking." Dishwashing at MacDonalds is hardly a picnic, but one can quit without being pursued by men with dogs, guns, and whips.

    --Martha King


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.