Monday, June 29, 2015

When Crying “Fire!” Becomes a Slur


photo: lPankonin

This past week witnessed two historical decisions ("'Equal Dignity,’" NYT, 6/27/15,  “Supreme Court Allows Nationwide Heath Care Subsidies,” NYT, 6/25/15) which reaffirmed not only the impartiality of the Supreme Court (with a Conservative Justice upholding the Affordable Care Act), but its imperturbability as an institution in comparison to an increasingly rambunctious and unstable congress. However, the next big decisions facing the Supreme Court are very likely to revolve around the limits of free speech. The famous Oliver Wendell Holmes decision in Schenck v. United States brilliantly prescribed limits to First Amendment Rights. But free expression is one of the most complex matters in jurisprudence and it regularly receives challenges from all sides of the ideological spectrum. This problem is particularly acute in the case of religious expression. Is wearing the Hijab, the veil worn by some Muslim women a right, when hiding one’s face makes identification documents like driver’s licenses and passports almost meaningless? Members of Canada’s conservative government recently courted controversy when they began to question this form of expression (“Harper says majority of 'moderate Muslims' support view on hijab ban,” The Globe and Mail, 3/15/15) Do militantly anti-Muslim groups have the right to promote offensive attacks on Muhammad like the cartoon contest recently held in Texas, under the guise of defending the right of free speech against those who would stifle it (“Pamela Geller, Organizer of Muhammad Cartoon Contest, Trumpets Results,NYT,  5/4/15).The latter might have given Oliver Wendell Holmes pause, as would have the case of the Nazis marching through the Jewish section of Skokie, Illinois (a case that never made it to the Supreme Court). At the recent PEN conference in New York, otherwise liberally inclined writers signed petitions against honoring surviving Charlie Hebdo staff members, an astonishing turn of events considering PEN’s storied history of defending writers and free expression around the world (“PEN Group Blacklists Charlie Hebdo,” The Screaming Pope, 4/29/15) Those who believe that questioning the First Amendment opens up a Pandora’s Box might ask how exactly “fire!” was cried, how crowded the theater and where the exits were. Salman Rushdie, who had a fatwah issued against him for The Satanic Verses, was incredulous and irate at the waffling some of his PEN colleagues, but the fire has now become the threat of violence and destruction. Liberal western values themselves are like crying “fire?” for fundamentalists of many stripes. In Israel the ultra Orthodox have attempted to inflict their values on a population that doesn’t always cotton to their values. In an age of increasing terrorism, there will be a tendency to constrict both the exercise of beliefs as well as the right to express opposition and outrage at those self-same beliefs. The Supreme Court will have its work cut for it.

1 comment:

  1. Perhaps it's because I'm a fan of louis vuitton replica the Sprouse in general,or maybe because my bearing is apparently the ambition admirers for pop-art fashion,or maybe it's just because my claimed aftertaste can,at times,adventure to the ridiculous.For whatever reason,I ambition I had absolute funds and a acumen to own something like the replica Louis Vuitton handbags.Its replica louis vuitton continued history and top acceptability are admired in actualization abode area.Abounding women dream of owning one LV handbags.However,the top amount generally abject.It's bigger than the accustomed wallets in the Cipher band so it can aswell be captivated as a clutch. It has a attachment and bifold breeze button cease for replica handbags bifold protection. them aback to reality.From the Rolex Datejust to the Breitling Bentley,you'll acquisition Jakarta alarm has a huge accumulating of watches for men's watches,women's watches and watches the child. the best replica watches accessible at.With hublot replica achievement affirmed and common delivery,it's simple to acquisition your admired artist replicas at the a lot of aggressive prices.You can blow assured that your adjustment will be absolutely what you see on the website,removing the accident of accepting something absolutely altered from what you expect.With cartier replica stainless animate construction,scratch-resistant azure crystal,and solid architecture application screws instead of pins,these replica watches will action you the best superior and a lot of reliable performance omega replica In the aboriginal years,Rolex Replicas aswell produced a baby amount of the 6200-series Rolex Submariner watches.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.